Customer Service
Everything an existing Keisler Insurance Group client needs in one place — file a claim, request a document, update a policy, or reach your carrier directly, including after hours.
What would you like to do?
Every request below goes straight to a licensed agent on our team. You will get a confirmation from a real person, not an automated queue.
Customer service, billing and claims contacts
For after-hours or direct carrier customer service, please use the directory of contacts below.
Travelers
Heritage Insurance
United Property and Casualty
Main Street America
National Grange (NGM)
Progressive
Progressive Flood
US Assure
Assurant Flood
Nationwide
Johnson and Johnson
Bankers
Foremost
Homeowners Insurance of America
Safeco
St Johns
After-hours claim reporting numbers
We can always help you file your claim during office hours. If you need to report a claim after hours, contact your carrier directly using the claim notification numbers below.
Allied Insurance
ASI
Assurant
Bankers
Dairyland
First Comp
Foremost
Grange Insurance
Johnson & Johnson
Main Street America
National Grange
Old Dominion
Progressive
Travelers
UPC Insurance
USAssure
Consolidation note for review
Both carrier directories from the old site now live on this one page, replacing the duplicate lists that appeared on /claims/ and /customer-service-contacts/. They are shown as two separate labelled tables on purpose: several carriers list different numbers in each source (Progressive claims is 800.274.4499 in the customer-service list and 800.925.2886 in the after-hours list; Travelers differs the same way). Please confirm with Jon Keisler which numbers are current before we merge them into a single table.
Can't find what you need?
You won't be left waiting on hold for hours or navigating through an endless maze of automated responses. Call us during office hours and you'll reach a real person who knows your policy.